Skip to main content

Abstract Evaluation Form

Please enter the unique identifier for the abstract.
This field is required.
Please provide the title of the abstract.
This field is required.
Please provide your full name.
This field is required.
Has the abstract been accepted or rejected?
This field is required.
How would you score the originality and innovation?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for originality and innovation.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) Novelty of idea<br>(ii) Potential to advance PA practice/education or medical knowledge<br>
This field is required.
How would you score the clarity of objectives/research question?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for clarity of objectives/research question.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) Clear statement of aims and objectives<br>(ii) Background sufficient to inform why the study was done<br>
This field is required.
How would you score the methodology and methods?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for methodology and methods.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) Methodology & Methods* Methods adopted appropriate to answer the research question(s)<br>(ii) The methodology is rigorous<br>(iii) There is clarity in the methods described<br>
This field is required.

*Methodology vs. Methods
Methodology

  • Refers to the overall research strategy or framework.
  • It answers: “Why was this approach chosen?” and “What is the rationale for using these methods?”
  • Example: Choosing a cross-sectional study design because it suits prevalence estimation.

Methods

  • Refers to the specific techniques, tools, and procedures used to collect and analyze data.
  • It answers: “How was the study conducted?”
  • Example: Using convenience sampling, administering a structured questionnaire, performing relevant statistics
How would you score the results/findings?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for results/findings.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) All relevant results provided<br>(ii) Results are presented clearly<br>
This field is required.
How would you score the conclusions and implications?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for conclusions and implications.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) Logically presented<br>(ii) Derived from results/ findings from the study and not out of assumption<br>
This field is required.
How would you score the structure, language, and clarity?
Choose a score between 1 and 10 for structure, language, and clarity.<br><br><strong>Evaluation criteria</strong><br>(i) Adherence to format<br>(ii) Readability<br>(iii) English Grammar<br>
This field is required.
This should be the sum of all scores provided.
This field is required.
Would you like to add an additional 10 points <strong>if the research is related to PA profession/practice/education</strong>? (Yes/No) (B)
Select yes if the research is relevant to PA profession/practice/education.
This field is required.
This should be the total score including any additional points.
This field is required.